An application to knock down a 25-metre high gum tree because it is causing structural damage and poses risks of limbs falling is set to be refused.
Subscribe now for unlimited access.
$0/
(min cost $0)
or signup to continue reading
The candlebark gum tree is at a veterinary hospital on the corner of William and Dora streets.
A development application has been lodged for its removal but a report by Orange City council staff to go to Tuesday night's council meeting said the tree should stay as it was healthy.
Supporting evidence from an Orange arborist accompanying the DA said the tree was potentially dangerous.
"Pruning the tree would only slightly reduce the risk of limb failures and would not change the root damage to footpaths, roads and building," the arborist said.
"Due to the tree's situation and such close proximity to main buildings, urban roads ways and services, I would recommend removal.
"The large tree is growing within three metres of the main business building, four metres from its carpark, two metres from the pedestrian footpath and six metres from the main road.
"Large heavy limbs are resting on the roof of the building and there is extensive damage to the footpath, driveway and building caused by roots."
Further supporting evidence shows pictures of cracks in the walls of the veterinary building and on the footpath.
However, a council officer and a report by a separate Orange arborist do not recommend the tree's removal.
The arborist recommended the tree be pruned.
"I believe this tree to be a healthy specimen with many years of amenity ahead of it," they said.
"The tree has reached its realistic potential in height and size (although a tree never stops growing until it dies).
"I believe the tree to be structurally sound, and an asset to the streetscape and the city. With proper pruning the tree could be rendered safer and its longevity thus ensured.
Tree removal will have adverse impacts on the heritage significance of this neighbourhood.
- Report to Orange City Council
"The tree should be subject to regular monitoring especially after extreme weather events."
The report recommends council refuse the demolition application on several grounds.
"The subject tree is a healthy specimen and structurally sound," it said.
"Tree removal will have adverse impacts on the heritage significance of this neighbourhood in the East Orange Heritage Conservation Area.
"Tree removal will have adverse visual impacts on the streetscape.
"Tree removal will have adverse impacts on the landscape setting in the locality."
A further report by the council's heritage officer said the tree was a landmark in the neighbourhood.
"The tree is of heritage value and complements the streetscape within the conservation area," they found.
"The tree is very tall for the area and acts as a landmark.
"The tree has aesthetic value and the tree is capable of modification and retention."
DO YOU WANT MORE ORANGE NEWS?
Receive our free newsletters delivered to your inbox, as well as breaking news alerts. Sign up below ...