Penrith Panthers v Newcastle Knights Panthers Knights Player Rating Player Rating Fullback Lachlan Coote 6 Wes Naiqama 6 Winger Rhys Wesser 6 James McManus 7 Winger Brad Tighe 6 Adam MacDougall 7 Centre Michael Jennings 6 Junior Sau 6 Centre Maurice Blair 6 Chris Houston 7 Five-eighth Wade Graham 6 Chris Bailey 6 Halfback Luke Lewis 6 Jarrod Mullen 7 Prop Tony Puletua 6 Daniel Tolar 6 Prop Petero Civoniceva 7 Matthew White 6 Hooker Masada Iosefa 6 Kurt Gidley 9 Second-row Frank Pritchard 6 Cameron Ciraldo 6 Second-row Trent Waterhouse 8 Cory Paterson 6 Lock Nathan Smith 6 Zeb Taia 7 Interchange Junior Moors 6 Danny Wicks 5 Interchange Luke Priddis 5 Richard Fa'aoso 7 Interchange Matthew Bell 6 Mark Taufua 5 Interchange Tim Grant 5 Scott Dureau 5
Judge: Greg Prichard, The Sydney Morning Herald Sydney Roosters v Gold Coast Titans Roosters Titans Player Rating Player Rating Fullback Amos Roberts 7 Preston Campbell 9 Winger Shaun Kenny-Dowall 6 Ben Jeffery 7 Winger Sam Perrett 6 Jordan Rapana 8 Centre Mitchell Aubusson 6 Josh Graham 7 Centre Setaimata Sa 7 Gavin Cooper 7 Five-eighth Braith Anasta 6 Mat Rogers 8 Halfback Mitchell Pearce 6 Brad Davis 7 Prop Mark O'Meley 7 James Stosic 7 Prop David Shillington 7 Michael Hodgson 7 Hooker Riley Brown 6 Nathan Friend 7 Second-row Willie Mason 6 Anthony Laffranchi 7 Second-row Anthony Cherrington 7 Will Matthews 7 Lock Craig Fitzgibbon 7 Daniel Conn 7 Interchange Lopini Paea 5 Michael Henderson 5 Interchange Frank-Paul Nuuausala 5 Matthew Cross 6 Interchange Brent Grose 5 Luke Swain 5 Interchange Jake Friend 5 Shannon Walker 6 Judge: Andrew Webster, The Sydney Morning Herald New Zealand Warriors v North Queensland Cowboys Warriors Cowboys Player Rating Player Rating Fullback Lance Hohaia 7 Mark Henry 6 Winger Malo Solomona 6 Brandon Boor 5 Winger Aidan Kirk 6 John Williams 7 Centre Brent Tate 7 Ashley Graham 6 Centre Sonny Fai 6 Ben Harris 6 Five-eighth Nathan Fien 6 Anthony Watts 5 Halfback Grant Rovelli 6 Johnathan Thurston 8 Prop Ruben Wiki 6 Ray Cashmere 7 Prop Steve Price 7
Ben Vaeau 6 Hooker Ian Henderson 5 Aaron Payne 6 Second-row Simon Mannering 7
Sione Faumuina 5 Second-row Logan Swann 5 Scott Bolton 6 Lock Micheal Luck 8 Steve Southern 6 Interchange Sam Rapira 6
Shane Tronc 7 Interchange Jerome Ropati 6 Ben Farrar 5 Interchange Evarn Tuimavave 5 Dayne Weston 5 Interchange Ben Matulino 6
Greg Byrnes 5
Judge: Aaron Lawton, Sunday News Cronulla Sharks v Manly Sea Eagles Sharks Sea Eagles Player Rating Player Rating Fullback Brett Kearney 7 Brett Stewart 7 Winger Misi Taulapa 5 Michael Robertson 8 Winger Luke Covell 5 David Williams 7 Centre Ben Pomeroy 6 Steve Bell 6 Centre David Simmons 6 Steve Matai 7 Five-eighth Brett Seymour 6 Jamie Lyon 7 Halfback Brett Kimmorley 5 Matt Orford 7 Prop Ben Ross 6 Brent Kite 8 Prop Luke Douglas 6 Josh Perry 7 Hooker Blake Green 6 Matt Ballin 7 Second-row Kade Snowden 6 Anthony Watmough 8 Second-row Fraser Anderson 6 Adam Cuthbertson 7 Lock Paul Gallen 8 Glenn Stewart 8 Interchange Adam Peek 6 Mark Bryant 7 Interchange Danny Nutley 6 Jason King 7 Interchange Isaac De Gois 6 Heath L'Estrange 6 Interchange Grant Millington 5 Steve Menzies 6
Judge: Will Swanton, The Sun-Herald South Sydney Rabbitohs v Parramatta Eels Rabbitohs Eels Player Rating Player Rating Fullback Nathan Merritt 7 Luke Burt 6 Winger Shannon Hegarty 7 Taulima Tautai 7 Winger Fetuli Talanoa 6 Jarryd Hayne 6 Centre Jamie Simpson 7 Krisnan Inu 7 Centre Beau Champion 7 Joel Reddy 5 Five-eighth Craig Wing 8 Feleti Mateo 8 Halfback Chris Sandow 9 Brett Finch 6 Prop Scott Geddes 7 Fuifui Moimoi 7 Prop Roy Asotasi 8 Josh Cordoba 6 Hooker Issac Luke 8 Mark Riddell 6 Second-row Luke Stuart 7 Nathan Hindmarsh 8 Second-row David Fa'alogo 8 Daniel Wagon 5 Lock John Sutton 7 Chad Robinson 6 Interchange Manase Manuokafoa 7 Todd Lowrie 6 Interchange David Kidwell 6 Weller Hauraki 7 Interchange Shannan McPherson 7 Brendan Oake 5 Interchange Beau Faloon 5 Matthew Keating 6
Judge: Adrian Proszenko, The Sun-Herald St George Illawarra Dragons v Canberra Raiders Dragons Raiders Player Rating Player Rating Fullback Brett Morris 6 David Milne 8 Winger Jason Nightingale 6 Colin Best 7 Winger Josh Morris 6 Adrian Purtell 8 Centre Mark Gasnier 6 Marshall Chalk 7 Centre Matt Cooper 7 Joel Monaghan 8 Five-eighth Jamie Soward 5 Terry Campese 7 Halfback Ben Hornby 6 Todd Carney 7 Prop Justin Poore 6 Troy Thompson 7 Prop Jason Ryles 6 Dane Tilse 7 Hooker Dean Young 6 Ryan Hinchcliffe 7 Second-row Beau Scott 6 Glen Turner 7 Second-row Jarrod Saffy 6 Joe Picker 7 Lock Lagi Setu 7 Alan Tongue 7 Interchange Kirk Reynoldson 5 Neville Costigan 5 Interchange Dan Hunt 5 Josh Miller 6 Interchange Rangi Chase 6 Scott Logan 6 Interchange Matt Prior 5 Trevor Thurling 7
Judge: Brad Walter, The Sydney Morning Herald Brisbane Broncos v Canterbury Bulldogs Broncos Bulldogs Player Rating Player Rating Fullback Karmichael Hunt 7 Brent Crisp 7 Winger Denan Kemp 6 Hazem El Masri 7 Winger Kaine Manihera 6 Heka Nanai 7 Centre Darius Boyd 5 Daryl Millard 6 Centre David Stagg 6 Tim Winitana 6 Five-eighth Darren Lockyer 6 Daniel Holdsworth 7 Halfback Peter Wallace 6 Arana Taumata 7 Prop Ben Hannant 7 Jarrad Hickey 6 Prop Joel Clinton 5 Fred Briggs 6 Hooker Michael Ennis 7 Corey Hughes 7 Second-row Corey Parker 7 Sonny Bill Williams 8 Second-row Sam Thaiday 7 Andrew Ryan 7 Lock Greg Eastwood 6 Reni Maitua 7 Interchange Ashton Sims 6 Chris Armit 5 Interchange Tonie Carroll 5 Ben Roberts 6 Interchange David Taylor 5 Lee Te Maari 6 Interchange Nick Emmett 4 John Kite 7 Judge: Glenn Jackson, The Sydney Morning Herald Wests Tigers v Melbourne Storm Tigers Storm Player Rating Player Rating Fullback Brett Hodgson 6 Billy Slater 9 Winger Taniela Tuiaki 5 Steve Turner 9 Winger Beau Ryan 6 Anthony Quinn 6 Centre Dean Collis 6 Matt Geyer 7 Centre Chris Lawrence 6 Israel Folau 6 Five-eighth Benji Marshall 5 Greg Inglis 8 Halfback John Morris 6 Cooper Cronk 7 Prop Keith Galloway 7 Jeff Lima 8 Prop Bryce Gibbs 6 Brett White 6 Hooker Robbie Farah 7 Cameron Smith 8 Second-row Bronson Harrison 8 Michael Crocker 7 Second-row Chris Heighington 7 Ryan Hoffman 6 Lock Dene Halatau 7 Dallas Johnson 7 Interchange Liam Fulton 6 Jeremy Smith 8 Interchange Ben Te'o 6 Adam Blair 7 Interchange Corey Payne 6 Sika Manu 8 Interchange Stuart Flanagan 5 Antonio Kafusi 6
Judge: Andrew Stevenson, The Sydney Morning Herald