News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Wettin wants a word to the wise on water 

Wettin wants a word to the wise on water

10 Feb, 2012 03:00 AM
BUSINESS owners in Orange should be concerned about the impact of the Macquarie pipeline, according to a spokesperson for the Orange and Region Water Security Alliance and Orange Ratepayers’ Association, Paul Wettin.

Mr Wettin, who has 30 years’ experience in water management, attempted to highlight what he perceives as the negative environmental and financial impacts of the pipeline during question time at an Orange Business Chamber meeting on Tuesday.

While he was denied the opportunity to address the chamber he was told he may be able to make a presentation at the next members only meeting later this month.

The chamber’s president Tony Healey said Tuesday’s meeting was designed as an information session with the presentation from Orange City Council staff Chris Devitt and Wayne Beatty not intended to be “a for or against” about the controversial topic.

Mr Wettin said he was concerned the council didn’t provide all the information regarding water security at the meeting including council’s existing contract with Cadia Valley Operations that sees the mine take all waste water from Orange at no cost.

Orange City Council’s Chris Devitt said council staff didn’t have time to cover every aspect of water management at the meeting.

“The presentation we did usually takes an hour,” he said.

“You could pick out 1000 things we didn’t say.”

While water security is the number one priority for Mr Wettin and the alliance, he believes the shortfall between the current yield and the amount of water required for Orange could be met with the stormwater harvesting scheme and the expansion of Suma Park Dam.

However, Mr Devitt said all options would be considered and justifications for discounting any alternatives would be included as part of the environmental assessment for the pipeline.

Mr Wettin said the council had not considered the impact of rising electricity prices on the operating costs of the pipeline which he believes will increase by around 70 per cent.

“Why isn’t council telling us this?” he said.

“It should be of critical importance to businesses especially those that are highly dependent on water use.”

While Mr Devitt would not “lock in” a running cost figure he said council was “painfully aware” of the impact of power prices and would look to optimise running costs.

Mr Wettin also questioned council’s calculations which based the total water requirement on water use of 400 litres per person per day when current level two restrictions saw residents only use about 200 litres per day.

Mr Devitt said the figures were designed to “leave some wriggle room” and needed to be read in context.

A draft environmental assessment for the project is expected to be finalised in the next six to eight weeks.

clare.colley@ruralpress. com

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Sounds like council only tells you what they want you to hear. Where's the representation? You're a council not a ruling junta! Good luck try to get both sides of the coin shown to the general public Mr Wettin, but keep going.
Posted by Ace Leuwin, 10/02/2012 5:19:43 AM, on Central Western Daily
Hate to break it to Mr Wettin but the Macquarie pipeline is a stormwater harvesting scheme so he is in essence arguing an oxymoron. Raising the dam wall does not increase the secure yield by a single drop, so as an isolated solution it achieves nothing.
Posted by Axiom, 10/02/2012 7:43:34 AM, on Central Western Daily
Council really does need to rethink the amount of water we use per day.

400 litres per person per day, sorry council no way

Last water bill we had was roughly 155 litres per person per day.


Posted by Westy, 10/02/2012 9:46:09 AM, on Central Western Daily
Suspect you will find it is an average that includes some very heavy users. Hey Ace I presume that Mr Wettin is telling an acurate story and not getting things a little wrong. I do not know but do you?
Posted by Bob, 10/02/2012 12:43:31 PM, on Central Western Daily
Ha Axiom - Nice try there but you will have to try harder.Which councillor are you ? Come clean with us all !!!
Posted by Water Works, 10/02/2012 12:57:19 PM, on Central Western Daily
The historionics on This Water Pipeline and the OBVIOUS flaws in water availability/ sinchronisation look like a cover up. If so, then what is it REALLY that the proponents are up to.
Posted by red herring, 10/02/2012 1:07:06 PM, on Central Western Daily
@Axiom

You seem to have different spin on things. Can you explain how the pipeline is the same as harvesting stormwater from the city? My thoughts have been that it is taking water from the Macquarie River which, in dry times when we will need the water, will already be struggling to flow. Am I thinking along the wrong lines here?

Also, how does raising the dam wall not increase yield? I agree that it is not a long term solution, but wouldn't it allow us to store extra in times like now when we are losing water due to the dam being at full capacity?

Posted by EL, 10/02/2012 2:56:37 PM, on Central Western Daily
Axiom, how can you believe drawing from the river is a stormwater harvesting scheme, it is a river, full of Bathursts sewage in times of low flow. Stormwater harvesting is the separate infrastrucure the council has spent $6 million dollars constructing, as you well know.

I remember now, you are an avid pipeline supporter, or a council stooge going on your previous comments on line, criticising all pipeline opponents.

OK it is your right, but base your comments on facts, not BS.

How did an emergency pipeline costing $9 million develop into a $47 million dollar nightmare?

Educate me!!

Posted by Gazzas, 10/02/2012 7:25:03 PM, on Central Western Daily
@Bob. He's got a sticker on his car. Looks pretty legit.
Posted by Ace Leuwin, 13/02/2012 10:15:40 AM, on Central Western Daily

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
EVERYONE’S BUSINESS: Orange and Region Water Security Alliance spokesperson Paul Wettin believes information about alternatives to the Macquarie pipeline project should be of “critical importance” to local businesses. Photo: CLARE COLLEY                         0209pipeline
EVERYONE’S BUSINESS: Orange and Region Water Security Alliance spokesperson Paul Wettin believes information about alternatives to the Macquarie pipeline project should be of “critical importance” to local businesses. Photo: CLARE COLLEY 0209pipeline

Most popular articles


Ryans Caravans
 


Central Western Daily







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...