News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Losing our old world charm 

Losing our old world charm

09 Feb, 2010 07:51 AM
THE owner of Endsleigh House says the integrity of the city’s oldest home will be compromised if a proposal to build three units nearby is approved by Orange City Council.

Rosemary Bagot, whose late husband Ted was a descendent of the home’s original builder Joseph Moulder, has lived in Endsleigh House for 30 years.

Built in 1858, Endsleigh House is recognised by Orange City Council as the city’s oldest standing house and is listed as an item of State heritage significance.

Mrs Bagot and other residents are concerned about the impacts on their neighbourhood if an application to build three units on a block adjacent to the historic home is approved by Orange City Council.

“This verandah is a great place to sit and relax but if this goes ahead I’ll look straight down to a pretty unattractively designed little unit located right on the street,” Mrs Bagot said yesterday.

“We’d be happy with two appropriate dwellings on the site but three is just far too many for the site and for the area.”

Council heritage advisor Christo Aitken has also recommended the developer consider a two-unit development rather than three.

He also suggested more “time and effort” could be dedicated to the design of the units.

An extensive heritage impact study will be prepared before the application is determined by Orange City Council.

Mrs Bagot’s daughter Barbara, an architect, said the family was not opposed to development on the block but was concerned about the proposal in its current form.

“At various stages over its life, the house has had its heritage value reduced and we don’t want that to continue,” she said.

Endsleigh Avenue resident Annella Powell, whose home is opposite the site, said the development could have broader implications if approved.

“It does have bigger implications for the city. We need to look at this whole urban infill issue and make sure we’re not going down a road we’ll regret in the future,” Ms Powell said.

“I would really be encouraging all councillors to stop for a minute and have a think.

“I’m not anti-development, I’m not against people developing property to maybe make a financial return but there needs to be consideration for those of us who moved here to enjoy not such a dense lifestyle.”

The Central Western Daily was unable to contact the applicants in Canberra yesterday.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
They list anything. The local area boasts a knocking shop and some hideous shop fronts. 3 units? who will notice or even care. Old doesn't necessarily imply historical significance. I see more historical significance in the stinky old sheep yards.
Posted by Millsy, 9/02/2010 10:24:24 AM
While ever "Development" Davis is in charge you can forget any attempt to introduce notions of equity, aesthetic sensibility and historical responsibility into heritage issues relating to the built environment in Orange. "Bugger Endsleigh House", "Devo" says, "my view won't be affected and besides, there's money to be made out of jimcrack development and the general application of a kind of small time, penny ante, krypto fascism. Bugger the hippies and the greenies and the historical wonks. What do they know? They couldn't fill out a development application to save their lives!" Davis should have stayed in Blayney. Let him turn their town into an aesthetic abattoir if they'd let him.
Posted by Mirriyuula, 9/02/2010 4:52:28 PM
Agreed, Millsy. Honestly, what do people expect--the end of building and development just because there might be a heritage house nearby? I live just around the corner. Since I became aware of its historicity, I have tried to get a glimpse of the old building. I can tell you that Endsleigh House is so sequestered by trees and (you guessed it) the surrounding, "modern" housing developments, that one might never know it existed.
Posted by CJ, 9/02/2010 11:47:24 PM
Millsy, CJ, I'm old and often sit surrounded by trees. Maybe I'm not worth worrying about either. Perhaps you'd have me bulldozed and replaced by some spotty idiot teenager. This is the oldest surviving domestic dwelling in Orange. For that reason alone it should be favoured in any assessment of any building application, the success of which might affect the visual amenity or integrity of Endsleigh House. It may mean nothing to you but it does mean a great deal to many others of us in the community, and more importantly is an integral part of the narrative of white settlement and development in Orange, not to mention being a compendium of building techniques and design and further a glimpse into a past that is vanishing all too quickly without any thought to the real human value of heritage. Will Orange be better served by another three cheap townhouses or by giving Endsleigh House the attention and precedence it deserves. It may be Rosemary's family home but there is a sense in which we all share an interest in its continued wellbeing and security.
Posted by Warrigal, 10/02/2010 1:00:18 PM
Well maybe they should cut all the trees down and turn it into another brothel. I've lived in older houses all over the country only to find I was being poisoned by lead paint and ddt residue. Odds on the building technique consists of slapping some nails in a few large pieces of wood, slapping some rock and brick on the outside and sticking a heap of tiles and lead on the roof. Fair dinkum building a house ain't rocket science.
Posted by Millsy, 10/02/2010 8:18:05 PM
Yeah yeah Warrigal. I don't see too many wattle and daub huts around Orange. They would have historical significance. I think the argument is about the area not the house in question. The area is already a mish mash of old, new and the delapidated. A few new houses ain't going to change what is essentially a streetscape uglyfest.
Posted by High Brow, 11/02/2010 8:58:47 AM
After a few at the Victoria and a quick hows your father I always stop at the Endsleigh house and admire it. Then I take a tinkle on the greenery and stumble home.
Posted by GoldenEagle, 11/02/2010 7:46:47 PM
Good to know that the venerable old pile is an important part of your daily routine Golden Eagle.Though I'm not sure Rosemary will thank you. But tell me GoldenEagle, while you're there doing the business in hand, do you look up and admire the simple lines of the house, do you wonder at its survival, do you, just for a moment, perhaps see it as it once was, a family farmhouse set on its hill just out of town, the rail line wouldn't come through for another 50 years. Come on GoldenEagle, admit it, you'd be sorry if you couldn't stop off for a tinkle and a wonder. How was her father by the way?
Posted by Mirriyuula, 12/02/2010 10:44:50 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
HISTORY UNDER THREAT: Rosemary Bagot, the owner of the city’s oldest house, is one of several Endsleigh Avenue residents concerned about a proposed unit development in the area.
HISTORY UNDER THREAT: Rosemary Bagot, the owner of the city’s oldest house, is one of several Endsleigh Avenue residents concerned about a proposed unit development in the area.

Most popular articles

Domain - search for local real estate agent
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...